Genre Basics

Historical Fiction vs Fantasy

How historical fiction and fantasy differ, where they overlap in historical fantasy and alternate history, and which books to try from each side.

On this page
  1. The core difference in one sentence
  2. What historical fiction is
  3. What fantasy is
  4. Side-by-side comparison
  5. Where the two genres meet
  6. What are the three types of historical fiction?
  7. What are the 7 elements of historical fiction?
  8. Is Harry Potter historical fiction or fantasy?
  9. What did C.S. Lewis say about fantasy?
  10. Which should you read next?

The core difference in one sentence

Historical fiction tells an invented story within the limits of what was really possible in a real past. Fantasy tells a story that includes the impossible, whether that’s magic, supernatural beings or an invented world.

Both are fiction. Both often feature castles, swords, kings and wars, which is why they get confused. The deciding question is simple: could this story have actually happened, given what we know about the period? If yes, it’s historical fiction. If the story needs magic or an imaginary world to work, it’s fantasy. If it’s somewhere in between, it may belong to one of the hybrid genres covered below.

What historical fiction is

Historical fiction places invented characters, and sometimes fictionalized real people, in a real historical period. The author’s job is to make the past feel vivid and believable: the clothes, food, politics, beliefs and daily textures of life.

How far in the past does a book need to be set? There’s no universal rule. The Historical Novel Society, for example, uses a guideline that a historical novel is generally written at least 50 years after the events it describes, or by someone who wasn’t alive at the time and so approaches the period through research. Other readers and publishers draw the line differently.

Well-known examples include:

  • Hilary Mantel’s Wolf Hall, which follows Thomas Cromwell at the court of Henry VIII and won the Booker Prize
  • Ken Follett’s The Pillars of the Earth, about the building of a cathedral in 12th-century England
  • Bernard Cornwell’s Saxon Stories (beginning with The Last Kingdom), set during the Viking invasions of England

Historical novelists do invent dialogue, private moments and whole characters, and some take deliberate liberties with known facts. But the genre’s basic promise to readers is that the world on the page follows the real rules of its time.

What fantasy is

Fantasy is fiction built on things that don’t exist in our reality, such as magic, mythical creatures, gods who walk the earth, or entirely invented worlds with their own histories. J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings, Ursula K. Le Guin’s A Wizard of Earthsea and Brandon Sanderson’s Mistborn are all fantasy, even though they draw on the look and feel of pre-modern societies.

That medieval look is a big source of confusion. Many fantasy worlds resemble historical Europe, Asia or the Middle East, but they aren’t our history. Middle-earth has no Rome, no Christianity and no real dates. The resemblance is atmosphere, not accuracy. For a deeper look at how fantasy relates to fiction as a whole, see our explainer on whether fantasy and fiction are the same.

Side-by-side comparison

Historical fiction Fantasy
Setting A real place and period from the past An invented world, or our world with impossible elements added
Rules The physical, social and technological limits of the era The author’s own rules, including magic or the supernatural
Real people Often appear, fictionalized Rarely, except in historical fantasy
Research Central. Accuracy is part of the appeal Optional. Worldbuilding replaces research
What readers expect To feel what the past was really like Wonder, strangeness and the impossible made real
Typical examples Wolf Hall, The Pillars of the Earth The Lord of the Rings, A Wizard of Earthsea

Where the two genres meet

The most interesting territory is the overlap. Several hybrid forms combine real history with fantastical elements, and they work differently from one another.

Historical fantasy in our own past

Historical fantasy takes a real period and adds magic or the supernatural. The history is recognizably ours, but something impossible is woven into it.

  • Susanna Clarke’s Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell imagines that English magic returns during the Napoleonic Wars.
  • Naomi Novik’s His Majesty’s Dragon (the first Temeraire book) gives the same wars an aerial corps of dragons. It’s one of our picks among the best fantasy books about dragons.
  • Helene Wecker’s The Golem and the Jinni follows two magical beings trying to pass as human in 1899 New York.

These books often do serious period research. The fantasy element is the one deliberate departure from history.

Secondary worlds modeled on real history

Some authors build invented worlds that closely echo specific historical periods without claiming to be them. Guy Gavriel Kay is the best-known example. His Under Heaven is set in a world inspired by Tang dynasty China, and he has described his approach as a “quarter turn to the fantastic.” Magic in these books is often subtle or minimal. George R.R. Martin has said the Wars of the Roses were one inspiration for A Song of Ice and Fire, though Westeros is fully its own world. Our A Game of Thrones book summary covers the first novel.

This approach gives authors freedom to change outcomes, compress timelines or explore themes without misrepresenting real people.

Alternate history

Alternate history asks “what if” a real historical event had gone differently. Philip K. Dick’s The Man in the High Castle imagines a world where the Axis powers won the Second World War. Alternate history doesn’t need magic at all, so it’s often shelved with science fiction rather than fantasy. When it does add magic, as in the Temeraire books, it overlaps with historical fantasy.

Myth and legend retellings

Retellings of myth and legend sit in a gray zone of their own. Madeline Miller’s The Song of Achilles and Circe are set in the mythic past of ancient Greece, with gods and monsters treated as real. They’re often shelved as literary or historical fiction but contain unmistakable fantasy elements. Arthurian novels such as T.H. White’s The Once and Future King work in a similar way. You’ll find these and related categories in our complete list of fantasy subgenres.

What are the three types of historical fiction?

There’s no single standard answer, and different teachers and writing guides divide the genre differently. One common way to group it, based on how a book treats the historical record:

  1. Traditional or realist historical fiction: stays within known history and real-world rules (Wolf Hall).
  2. Alternate history: changes a real historical event and follows the consequences (The Man in the High Castle).
  3. Historical fantasy: keeps a real historical setting but adds magic or the supernatural (Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell).

Other breakdowns sort historical novels by how they treat real people, for example stories centered on real historical figures versus invented characters set against real events. Some add categories such as historical mystery or historical romance. If you’ve encountered a different “three types” list in a class, it isn’t necessarily wrong. The term simply isn’t fixed.

What are the 7 elements of historical fiction?

Lists of the “elements of historical fiction” vary too, but they usually adapt the standard elements of fiction to the demands of the genre. A typical list includes:

  1. Setting: a real time and place, rendered with accurate detail
  2. Characters: invented or real people whose beliefs and behavior fit their era
  3. Plot: events that could plausibly have happened, often tied to real history
  4. Conflict: struggles shaped by the period’s politics, wars, social rules or values
  5. Theme: ideas that connect the past to lasting human questions
  6. Point of view: whose eyes we see the period through
  7. Authentic language and detail: dialogue and description that evoke the era without becoming unreadable

Fantasy shares most of these elements. The key difference is the first one. In historical fiction, setting is borrowed from reality and checked against it. In fantasy, setting is invented and only has to be consistent with itself.

Is Harry Potter historical fiction or fantasy?

Harry Potter is fantasy, not historical fiction. It’s set in 1990s Britain, close to when the books were written, and it’s built around magic and a hidden wizarding world. It doesn’t try to recreate a real historical period, which is the defining feature of historical fiction.

What did C.S. Lewis say about fantasy?

C.S. Lewis, author of The Chronicles of Narnia and a scholar of medieval and Renaissance literature, wrote about fantasy and fairy tales in several essays. A few of his best-known points:

  • In “On Three Ways of Writing for Children,” he argued that a children’s story enjoyed only by children is a bad children’s story, and that adults needn’t be embarrassed to love fairy tales.
  • In the same essay he suggested that fantasy is less likely to deceive readers than supposedly realistic fiction. He recalled never expecting the real world to be like fairy tales, while realistic stories had given him false expectations about life.
  • His dedication of The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe to his goddaughter Lucy Barfield includes the line that “some day you will be old enough to start reading fairy tales again.”

Lewis’s view is a useful counterweight to the idea that historical fiction is the “serious” choice and fantasy the frivolous one. In his view, fantasy could say true things about people precisely because it didn’t pretend to describe the real world.

The right choice depends on what you enjoy most:

  • If you love the texture of real history, such as court politics, period detail and real figures, start with historical fiction like Wolf Hall or The Pillars of the Earth.
  • If you love invention and wonder, start with secondary-world fantasy like A Wizard of Earthsea or The Lord of the Rings (and if that one clicks, try these fantasy books like The Lord of the Rings).
  • If you want both, historical fantasy is the obvious bridge. Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell, His Majesty’s Dragon and The Golem and the Jinni each take a real period seriously while adding something impossible. Two of them also appear in our guide to fantasy books for people who don’t like fantasy.
  • If you want history reimagined, try Guy Gavriel Kay’s novels or alternate history like The Man in the High Castle.

Many readers end up enjoying both genres for the same reason: each one takes you somewhere you can’t otherwise go.

The complete guide to genre basics

Are Fantasy and Fiction the Same? (And Can Fantasy Be Literary?)
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →