What makes Dungeon Crawler Carl hard to replace
Dungeon Crawler Carl by Matt Dinniman mixes things that rarely appear together: crunchy LitRPG mechanics, an angry satire of reality TV and corporate cruelty, real grief and horror, and some of the funniest scenes in the genre. Then there’s Princess Donut, the talking show cat. It’s widely considered the most popular LitRPG series, and no single book matches all of it.
The best approach is to decide which part you loved most and follow that. The sections below are organized that way.
Quick picks
- Closest overall match: He Who Fights with Monsters by Shirtaloon
- Funniest LitRPG: Everybody Loves Large Chests by Neven Iliev (crude, explicit)
- Best town-building comedy: Mayor of Noobtown by Ryan Rimmel
- Best system apocalypse: The Primal Hunter by Zogarth
- Best death-game classic: The Running Man by Stephen King, writing as Richard Bachman
- Best snarky sci-fi narrator: All Systems Red by Martha Wells
LitRPG with dark humor and apocalypse stakes
He Who Fights with Monsters by Shirtaloon. Jason Asano is pulled into a world of magic and adventuring and copes with it by talking, joking and refusing to take anything seriously, until he has to. It shares Carl’s mix of banter and genuinely dark turns, and the audiobooks, narrated by Heath Miller, are very popular. It’s long and ongoing, and the pace slows in places.
The Primal Hunter by Zogarth. Earth is pulled into a game-like System, and Jake Thayne turns out to be terrifyingly good at it. There’s less comedy than in DCC, but if you liked the leveling, builds and boss fights, it hits those notes hard. Travis Baldree narrates.
Defiance of the Fall by TheFirstDefier and JF Brink. Another system apocalypse, mixing LitRPG screens with cultivation. It’s more serious in tone and grows to a huge, cosmic scale. Good if you want the apocalypse-survival side without the jokes.
Comedy-forward LitRPG
Mayor of Noobtown by Ryan Rimmel. A LitRPG about running a starter village, played for broad, silly comedy. The stakes are lower than DCC’s, but the absurdity scratches a similar itch.
Everybody Loves Large Chests by Neven Iliev. The protagonist is a mimic, a monster disguised as a treasure chest, and the books are gleefully gross, violent and funny. Fair warning: it includes explicit content and very crude humor. The audiobooks feature a large cast, much like the bigger DCC productions. The series is complete; see our list of finished progression fantasy and complete LitRPG series for more series with endings.
The Completionist Chronicles by Dakota Krout. A lighter VRMMO adventure about a player obsessed with completing everything. It’s less dark than DCC but heavy on game humor and progression.
Dungeon and tower progression with sharper plotting
If what kept you reading was the floor-by-floor structure and the sense that every rule might matter later, try these:
- Sufficiently Advanced Magic by Andrew Rowe. Corin Cadence climbs a deadly magical tower to find his missing brother. Tactical problem-solving and a carefully explained magic system.
- Cradle by Will Wight. Not LitRPG, but fast, escalating and finished, with a lot of humor in the later books.
- Mother of Learning by Domagoj Kurmaić. A time-loop story with excellent long-term plotting. Readers who enjoy Dinniman’s foreshadowing often like it.
- Delve by SenescentSoul. For readers who want even more numbers than Carl’s.
For more along these lines, see what are some good progression fantasy series.
Death games and deadly game shows
Part of DCC’s bite comes from a much older tradition of stories about deadly entertainment for a watching audience.
- The Running Man by Stephen King, writing as Richard Bachman (1982). A desperate man joins a lethal TV game show in a bleak future America. It’s short, angry and very close in spirit to DCC’s satire. For more bleak futures in a compact form, see our dystopian sci-fi short stories.
- Battle Royale by Koushun Takami (1999). A class of students is forced to fight to the death under government orders. Brutal and influential.
- The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins. The best-known modern take: survival as televised spectacle, with sponsors and audience manipulation that DCC readers will recognize.
Snarky science fiction with a similar voice
If Carl’s narration and the gallows humor were the draw, these non-LitRPG picks share the voice:
- All Systems Red by Martha Wells. The first Murderbot novella. A security android that would rather watch TV shows than deal with humans narrates with deadpan sarcasm. It’s short, sharp and part of a longer series, and it’s one of our picks among new sci-fi books for adult readers.
- We Are Legion (We Are Bob) by Dennis E. Taylor. A software engineer wakes up as the AI of a space probe and starts copying himself across the galaxy. Nerdy, funny and easygoing.
- The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy by Douglas Adams. The classic of an ordinary man surviving Earth’s destruction while the universe proves absurd. Carl’s situation owes it something.
More from Matt Dinniman
Dinniman has written other books outside the DCC series. Kaiju: Battlefield Surgeon is the one most often recommended to DCC fans: a comic science fiction novel about patching up giant fighting monsters. It has his sense of humor, though it’s less focused on game mechanics.
Tips for finding your next DCC
- Decide what you want more of: jokes, stats, horror, satire or companions. No book has all of them, but most have two or three.
- Sample the audiobook. Much of DCC’s reputation comes from its narration, so a good narrator matters when picking a replacement.
- Check content notes. Some comedic LitRPG goes much further than DCC into explicit material.
- Look for monster or undead leads if you enjoyed the stranger character builds. Our list of LitRPG necromancer books is a good place to start.
- Learn the tags. “System apocalypse” is the label for stories where a game arrives on Earth, as in DCC. Our explainer on LitRPG vs progression fantasy vs cultivation covers the rest.
- Try The Wandering Inn if you want an enormous, character-driven world with levels. See our Wandering Inn series guide.