Magic Fantasy

What fantasy books are recommended for a book club?

The fantasy books that work best for book clubs, from Piranesi and Circe to cozy picks, with discussion angles, length notes and tips for running the meeting.

On this page
  1. The short answer
  2. What makes a fantasy book work for a book club
  3. Picks for groups new to fantasy
  4. Picks for groups who already love fantasy
  5. Cozy and feel-good choices
  6. Folklore and fairy-tale picks
  7. At a glance
  8. Discussion questions that work for almost any fantasy book
  9. Tips for running a fantasy book club

The short answer

The fantasy books most often recommended for book clubs are standalones with big themes and manageable length. Strong starting points include Piranesi by Susanna Clarke, Circe by Madeline Miller, The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern, The Buried Giant by Kazuo Ishiguro, Spinning Silver by Naomi Novik and Babel by R.F. Kuang. Each tells a complete story in one volume and leaves a group with plenty to argue about.

Below, we explain what makes a fantasy novel work for a group and suggest picks for different kinds of clubs.

What makes a fantasy book work for a book club

A book that’s wonderful to read alone isn’t always good for discussion. For groups, look for:

  • A complete story. Standalones, or first books with a satisfying ending, avoid leaving half the group needing to buy a sequel.
  • Reasonable length. Something most members can finish in three or four weeks; our list of short fantasy books under 300 pages is a good place to look. Doorstop epics tend to cause no-shows.
  • Themes beyond the plot. Memory, power, identity, family, colonialism, grief — fantasy is good at these, and they give groups something to debate.
  • An easy way in. If some members don’t usually read fantasy, choose a book that doesn’t open with pages of invented history and unfamiliar names.
  • Room to disagree. Ambiguous endings and morally complicated characters make for livelier meetings than books everyone simply enjoys.

Picks for groups new to fantasy

Piranesi by Susanna Clarke (2020)

A man lives alone in a vast House of endless halls, statues and tidal seas, and keeps a careful journal of everything he finds. Who he is, and how he got there, unfolds slowly. It’s short, beautifully written and won the Women’s Prize for Fiction in 2021. Discuss: What does the House mean to him, and is leaving it a loss or a rescue?

Circe by Madeline Miller (2018)

A retelling of Greek myth from the point of view of the witch who turns Odysseus’s men into pigs, and one of our picks among the best fantasy books about witches. It follows her over centuries of exile, craft and motherhood. Familiar mythology makes it approachable for non-fantasy readers. Discuss: How does Circe’s view of gods and mortals change, and what does she gain by choosing her own life?

The Night Circus by Erin Morgenstern (2011)

Two young magicians are bound into a long, mysterious contest, played out through a black-and-white circus that opens only at night. It’s atmospheric rather than fast. Discuss: Is the contest a love story, a cage, or both?

The Buried Giant by Kazuo Ishiguro (2015)

An elderly couple travels across a post-Arthurian Britain covered by a mist that makes everyone forget. It’s quiet and literary, from a Nobel-winning author. Discuss: Is it better for individuals — or nations — to remember painful history, or to forget it?

The Golem and the Jinni by Helene Wecker (2013)

Two magical beings, one made of clay and one of fire, try to pass as human among immigrant communities in 1899 New York. Discuss: What does each creature’s nature say about freedom, duty and belonging?

Picks for groups who already love fantasy

Uprooted (2015) or Spinning Silver (2018) by Naomi Novik

Both are standalone novels drawing on Eastern European folklore. Uprooted, which won the Nebula Award for Best Novel, follows a village girl taken to serve a wizard and a corrupted, living forest. Spinning Silver reworks Rumpelstiltskin through several narrators, including a Jewish moneylender’s daughter. Discuss: How do debts, bargains and promises shape these characters’ choices?

The Fifth Season by N.K. Jemisin (2015)

The first book of the Broken Earth trilogy, set on a continent of devastating earthquakes where people who can control seismic energy are feared and exploited. It won the Hugo Award for Best Novel. Its structure is unusual, which is a discussion topic in itself. It is part of a trilogy, so the group may want to continue. Discuss: How does the book treat oppression, survival and motherhood?

Babel by R.F. Kuang (2022)

At an institute of translation in 1830s Oxford, magic works through the meaning lost between words in different languages — and powers the British Empire. It’s long and argumentative by design. Discuss: Can you work inside an unjust system to change it?

Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke (2004)

Two rival magicians restore English magic during the Napoleonic Wars, in a witty, footnoted novel that won the Hugo Award for Best Novel. It’s very long, so consider splitting it across two meetings.

Cozy and feel-good choices

  • Legends & Lattes by Travis Baldree (2022): a retired orc warrior opens a coffee shop. Low stakes, warm and short — good for a lighter month. Discuss: What does starting over look like?
  • The House in the Cerulean Sea by TJ Klune (2020): a by-the-book caseworker is sent to inspect an island orphanage for magical children. Discuss: How do rules and kindness clash in the story?
  • Tress of the Emerald Sea by Brandon Sanderson (2023): a standalone adventure inspired by The Princess Bride, a gentle introduction to a hugely popular author.

Folklore and fairy-tale picks

  • The Bear and the Nightingale by Katherine Arden (2017): a girl in medieval Russia defends the household spirits of old belief against a new, fearful faith. It begins a trilogy but stands on its own reasonably well.
  • The Ten Thousand Doors of January by Alix E. Harrow (2019): a young woman in early-1900s America finds a book about doors between worlds. Good for groups who enjoy stories about stories.

At a glance

Book Standalone? Feel Big discussion themes
Piranesi Yes Short, mysterious Identity, solitude, wonder
Circe Yes Mythic, intimate Power, gender, choice
The Night Circus Yes Dreamy, slow Love, control, art
The Buried Giant Yes Quiet, literary Memory, forgiveness
Spinning Silver Yes Folkloric Debt, prejudice, agency
The Fifth Season Trilogy opener Challenging Oppression, survival
Babel Yes Long, intense Empire, language, resistance
Legends & Lattes Yes (with a prequel) Cozy, short Second chances, community

Discussion questions that work for almost any fantasy book

  1. What does the magic (or the impossible element) represent beyond the plot?
  2. Which rules of this world did you find most believable, and which didn’t work for you?
  3. Did the setting feel like a place you’d want to visit? Why or why not?
  4. Which character changed the most, and was the change earned?
  5. How does the book reflect real-world issues, even if it never mentions them directly?
  6. Would the story have worked as realistic fiction? What would be lost?

That last question is a good way to bring in members who say they “don’t read fantasy” — and if the group debates whether a book even counts as fantasy, our guide on how to tell if a book is fantasy is a useful companion.

Tips for running a fantasy book club

  • Check content notes in advance. Some fantasy deals with violence, abuse or self-harm; a quick heads-up helps members decide.
  • Agree on series policy. Decide early whether first-in-series books are allowed, and whether the group will continue together.
  • Offer audiobook and ebook options. Invented names are easier for some readers to follow by ear, and audio helps busy members keep up.
  • Rotate moods. Alternate heavier picks like Babel with lighter ones like Legends & Lattes.
  • Theme a season. A run of fantasy books set in magical libraries or magic school fantasy for adults gives a club a shared thread. For longer commitments, our guide to the best magic fantasy book series can help a group choose one to follow together.

The complete guide to magic fantasy

The Best Magic Fantasy Book Series
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →