Classic and Pulp Fantasy

The Best Fantasy Short Stories of All Time

A guide to the best fantasy short stories of all time, from Dunsany and Robert E. Howard to Le Guin, Leiber and Ken Liu, with notes on where to read them.

On this page
  1. How we chose these stories
  2. Early foundations
  3. The pulp era: sword and sorcery and weird fantasy
  4. Mid-century classics
  5. Modern landmarks
  6. So what is the greatest fantasy story ever?
  7. Short stories vs. novellas
  8. Anthologies that collect the best of the genre
  9. Where to read them free
  10. Where to start

Fantasy is often sold by the pound: trilogies, ten-book series, doorstoppers with maps in the front. But much of the genre’s best work is short. Sword and sorcery was born in magazine stories. Many of the ideas modern fantasy takes for granted were first tried out in a few thousand words, and some of the most discussed fantasy ever written fits in a single sitting.

This list collects fantasy short stories that readers and critics keep coming back to. It runs from early literary fairy tales through the pulp era to contemporary award winners. It isn’t a definitive ranking (no list could be), but every story here has a strong claim to a place in the conversation.

How we chose these stories

We looked for stories that meet at least one of these tests:

  • Influence: the story shaped what came after it, or helped define a subgenre.
  • Staying power: it is still reprinted, taught or discussed decades later.
  • Recognition: it won major awards or is a fixture of best-of anthologies.
  • Readability today: it still works for a modern reader, not only as a historical artefact.

We kept to genuinely short fiction where we could. A few longer pieces are noted along the way. For book-length-but-brief works, see our separate guide to the best fantasy novellas.

Early foundations

These stories predate fantasy as a marketing category, but modern fantasy grows directly out of them.

“The Golden Pot” — E.T.A. Hoffmann (1814)

A clumsy student in Dresden stumbles into a hidden world of salamanders, serpent-women and rival magicians. Hoffmann’s tale is one of the cornerstones of German Romantic fantasy. It sets a fully magical world running just behind ordinary city life, an idea urban fantasy still uses two centuries later.

“The Snow Queen” — Hans Christian Andersen (1844)

Andersen’s longest fairy tale follows Gerda’s journey to rescue her friend Kay, whose heart has been frozen by a splinter of a demon’s mirror. It is told in seven linked stories, and it has the shape of a quest fantasy in miniature.

“The Golden Key” — George MacDonald (1867)

MacDonald influenced both C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien. “The Golden Key” is a strange, dreamlike story of two children travelling through Fairyland toward a country “from which the shadows fall”. It is worth reading for its sense of the numinous, which later fantasy often reaches for and rarely achieves.

Lord Dunsany’s tales (1905–1919)

Lord Dunsany wrote dozens of short fantasies set in invented lands, in a style that sounds like a translated scripture. Good starting points:

  • “Idle Days on the Yann” (in A Dreamer’s Tales, 1910): a slow river journey through impossible cities.
  • “The Hoard of the Gibbelins” (in The Book of Wonder, 1912): a short, sardonic treasure-hunt story with a famous final line.
  • “The Fortress Unvanquishable, Save for Sacnoth” (in The Sword of Welleran, 1908): a hero, a magic sword and a sorcerer’s castle. It is a template for countless later adventures.

Dunsany’s influence on Lovecraft, Tolkien, Le Guin and many others is hard to overstate. Most of his early work is in the public domain in the US, and our guide to public domain fantasy stories covers where to find it free.

The pulp era: sword and sorcery and weird fantasy

In the 1920s and 1930s, cheap American fiction magazines (above all Weird Tales) gave fantasy a new, faster and darker voice. If you’re unfamiliar with the term, our explainer on what pulp fantasy is covers the background.

“The Tower of the Elephant” — Robert E. Howard (1933)

A young Conan, working as a thief, climbs a sorcerer’s tower to steal a jewel. He finds something far stranger and sadder than he expected. Many readers consider this the best Conan story. It shows that Howard could do wonder and melancholy as well as action. “Red Nails” (1936) and “Beyond the Black River” (1935) are also frequently named among his best, though both run to novella length. Our guide to Howard’s Conan books covers which editions to read.

“Black God’s Kiss” — C.L. Moore (1934)

Jirel of Joiry, a fierce medieval warrior-queen, is defeated and humiliated by an invading lord. She descends into a nightmarish otherworld to find a weapon for her revenge. Jirel is often cited as the first major female protagonist in sword and sorcery. The story’s eerie, sensory strangeness has aged remarkably well.

“The Dark Eidolon” — Clark Ashton Smith (1935)

Smith’s Zothique stories are set on Earth’s last continent, under a dying sun. “The Dark Eidolon” is a tale of a necromancer’s revenge, written in Smith’s ornate, jewelled prose. It is not to everyone’s taste, but nobody else wrote quite like him.

H.P. Lovecraft’s dream stories

Lovecraft is known mainly for cosmic horror. But his Dunsany-influenced “Dream Cycle” is outright fantasy. “The Doom That Came to Sarnath” and “Celephaïs” are short entry points. The Dream-Quest of Unknown Kadath is a longer, novella-length journey through the same dreamlands.

Mid-century classics

“Leaf by Niggle” — J.R.R. Tolkien (1945)

A painter named Niggle spends his life trying to finish a picture of a single, enormous tree. Interruptions keep defeating him, and then he is sent on a journey he cannot refuse. Tolkien’s short allegory about art, duty and grace is very different from Middle-earth, and many readers find it among his most moving work.

“Liane the Wayfarer” — Jack Vance (1950)

This story comes from The Dying Earth, Vance’s collection set in a far-future world where magic has replaced science and the sun is guttering out. Liane is a vain, swaggering adventurer who meets a terrible creature called Chun the Unavoidable. The story is a masterclass in irony and baroque dialogue.

“Ill Met in Lankhmar” — Fritz Leiber (1970)

This is the story of how the barbarian Fafhrd and the thief the Gray Mouser first met, and of the night that bound them together for life. It is witty, swashbuckling and genuinely tragic. It won both the Hugo and the Nebula awards for best novella. It is also the natural starting point for our Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser reading order.

“The Rule of Names” — Ursula K. Le Guin (1964)

This is a light, funny story about a seemingly harmless village wizard. It introduced the idea of true names that became central to Le Guin’s Earthsea books. It and its companion “The Word of Unbinding” (also 1964) are often read as preludes to A Wizard of Earthsea.

“The Library of Babel” — Jorge Luis Borges (1941)

Borges is usually shelved as literary fiction, but his stories are fantasies of the purest kind. “The Library of Babel” imagines a universe made of an endless library that contains every possible book. Its ideas about infinity and meaning have influenced writers across many genres.

Modern landmarks

“The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas” — Ursula K. Le Guin (1973)

A joyous city’s happiness depends on the misery of one child, and every citizen knows it. Le Guin’s short philosophical fable won the Hugo Award. It may be the most widely taught and debated fantasy story of the last half-century.

The Bloody Chamber — Angela Carter (1979)

This isn’t a single story but a collection of reworked fairy tales: Bluebeard, Beauty and the Beast, Red Riding Hood and others. It is dark, sensual and very influential. The title story and “The Company of Wolves” are the best-known pieces.

“Two Hearts” — Peter S. Beagle (2005)

A girl sets out to get the king’s help against a griffin that is terrorising her village. Along the way she meets some familiar faces from Beagle’s The Last Unicorn. It won both the Hugo and the Nebula. You can read it without the novel, though it means more if you have.

A girl’s grandmother owns a handbag that may contain an entire village, and the girl’s boyfriend has disappeared inside it. Link’s work is playful, odd and emotionally sharp, and this story won the Hugo, Nebula and Locus awards.

“The Merchant and the Alchemist’s Gate” — Ted Chiang (2007)

This is a time-travel story told like a tale from The Thousand and One Nights, with stories nested inside a story. Chiang usually writes science fiction, but this one is told as a fable, and it won both the Hugo and the Nebula.

“The Paper Menagerie” — Ken Liu (2011)

A Chinese mother folds origami animals that come to life for her American-born son, until he begins to reject her and her language. It was the first work of fiction to win the Hugo, Nebula and World Fantasy awards. Readers regularly describe it as one of the saddest stories they have ever read.

So what is the greatest fantasy story ever?

There’s no single answer, and anyone who offers one is giving an opinion. If you press fantasy readers for one short story, though, two names come up again and again:

  • “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas” for its moral weight and influence beyond the genre.
  • “The Paper Menagerie” for its emotional impact and unusual awards record.

Among sword-and-sorcery fans, “Ill Met in Lankhmar” and “The Tower of the Elephant” are the usual answers. Fans of older literary fantasy tend to name Dunsany or MacDonald.

People asking for the “greatest short story of all time” across all literature usually get names like Chekhov, Joyce, Borges and Poe. Borges is the one who sits most comfortably in both conversations.

Short stories vs. novellas

Some favourite “short” fantasy is actually novella length: The Emperor’s Soul by Brandon Sanderson, Every Heart a Doorway by Seanan McGuire, Howard’s “Red Nails”, and Tolkien’s Smith of Wootton Major. Lists often mix the two. If you enjoy fiction that is complete in an evening or two, our guide to the best fantasy novellas picks up where this one leaves off.

Anthologies that collect the best of the genre

If you would rather buy one book than hunt down twenty, these anthologies are good places to look:

  • The Big Book of Classic Fantasy (edited by Ann and Jeff VanderMeer, 2019): a huge survey of fantasy from the 19th and early 20th centuries, including many translated works.
  • The Weird (edited by Ann and Jeff VanderMeer, 2011): a century of strange and dark fiction, with a lot of fantasy among the horror.
  • The Sword & Sorcery Anthology (edited by David G. Hartwell and Jacob Weisman, 2012): Howard, Moore, Leiber, Moorcock and later writers in one volume.
  • The Year’s Best Fantasy and Horror (edited by Ellen Datlow and Terri Windling, 1988–2008): a long-running annual series. Older volumes are a rich source for the 1980s–2000s.

Single-author collections are often the best value of all. Le Guin’s The Wind’s Twelve Quarters, Link’s Magic for Beginners, Liu’s The Paper Menagerie and Other Stories and Chiang’s Exhalation are all strong.

Where to read them free

Many of the older stories on this list are in the public domain in the United States. That includes much of Andersen, MacDonald and early Dunsany, and some of Howard’s and Lovecraft’s magazine fiction. Project Gutenberg, Standard Ebooks and LibriVox (for audio) are reliable free sources. Our list of public domain fantasy stories and Project Gutenberg picks goes into detail. More recent stories are still under copyright. Some award winners have been published free online by the magazines that first ran them, but availability changes, so check the publisher’s site.

Where to start

If you only read three stories from this list, a balanced set would be:

  1. “The Hoard of the Gibbelins” (Dunsany) for the classic voice of invented-world fantasy, in about ten minutes.
  2. “Ill Met in Lankhmar” (Leiber) for sword and sorcery at its peak.
  3. “The Paper Menagerie” (Liu) for what modern short fantasy can do.

From there, follow whichever thread you enjoyed most. If it was the swordplay, our introduction to sword and sorcery and its classic books is a good next step, as is the Elric reading order. If it was the strangeness, go back to Dunsany, Smith and Borges. If it was the emotional punch, read more Le Guin, Link and Liu.

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →