Classic and Pulp Fantasy

What Is Pulp Fantasy?

What pulp fantasy means: where the term comes from, the magazines and writers that defined it, its typical traits, and how it differs from epic fantasy.

On this page
  1. Pulp fantasy, defined
  2. What “pulp” means in literature
  3. The magazines that published pulp fantasy
  4. Hallmarks of pulp fantasy
  5. Key writers and examples
  6. Pulp fantasy vs. epic fantasy
  7. Pulp fantasy in games: Appendix N
  8. Is pulp fantasy still written?
  9. Where to start reading

Pulp fantasy, defined

Pulp fantasy is fantasy fiction published in, or written in the style of, the cheap American fiction magazines of roughly the 1920s to the 1950s, known as “the pulps”. In practice the term describes a recognisable kind of story. It is fast-moving, vivid and adventurous, often dark or eerie, built around a strong central hero, and written to grip a reader from the first page.

The best-known examples are Robert E. Howard’s Conan stories, Clark Ashton Smith’s tales of dying worlds, C.L. Moore’s Jirel of Joiry and Fritz Leiber’s Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser. Today “pulp fantasy” can also describe newer fiction (and games) that deliberately recaptures that spirit.

What “pulp” means in literature

The word comes from the paper. Pulp magazines were printed on cheap, coarse paper made from wood pulp, rough-edged and quick to yellow. Better-funded magazines printed on smooth coated paper were called “slicks”. The difference in paper came to stand for a difference in reputation. Slicks were seen as respectable, and pulps as popular entertainment for a mass audience.

A typical pulp ran to about 7 by 10 inches and around 128 pages, and for many years most cost about ten cents. Frank Munsey’s Argosy, which switched to all-fiction pulp format in the 1890s, is usually considered the first. By the 1920s and 1930s there were hundreds of titles. Each was usually dedicated to a single genre: detective, western, romance, air war, science fiction, horror and fantasy.

Pulp writers were generally paid by the word, often a cent or less. That pushed them toward high output, strong hooks and relentless pace. Some were hacks; others, such as Dashiell Hammett, Raymond Chandler and Robert E. Howard, became classics.

The word “pulp” is now also used more loosely for any lurid, fast-paced genre fiction. That’s the sense behind Quentin Tarantino’s 1994 film Pulp Fiction. But historically pulp was a medium, not a genre. Fantasy was just one of the many kinds of story it carried.

The magazines that published pulp fantasy

  • Weird Tales (founded 1923). This was the essential home of pulp fantasy, and its original run lasted until 1954. Under editor Farnsworth Wright it published Howard’s Conan, Kull and Solomon Kane stories, Clark Ashton Smith, C.L. Moore, H.P. Lovecraft and many others. Its covers, especially Margaret Brundage’s 1930s paintings, are still famous.
  • Argosy and All-Story. These general adventure pulps serialised Edgar Rice Burroughs (Under the Moons of Mars, later published as A Princess of Mars) and A. Merritt’s lost-world fantasies.
  • Unknown (1939–1943). This short-lived magazine was edited by John W. Campbell. It favoured witty, logical fantasy over gothic horror, and it debuted Leiber’s Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser and de Camp and Pratt’s Harold Shea stories.
  • Planet Stories and similar adventure-SF pulps. Leigh Brackett’s sword-swinging tales of Mars and Venus blurred the line between science fiction and fantasy.

Hallmarks of pulp fantasy

Pulp fantasy was never a formal genre with rules, but most of it shares several traits:

  • Speed. Stories open in the middle of the action and rarely slow down.
  • Short length. Most pulp fantasy was short stories and novelettes, with the occasional serial. Big trilogies came later.
  • A strong, often recurring hero. Barbarians, swordswomen, thieves and adventurers return issue after issue.
  • Personal stakes. The hero is usually after survival, treasure, revenge or escape, not saving the world.
  • Sinister magic. Sorcery is usually dangerous, ancient and in the hands of villains.
  • Exotic, decadent settings. Lost cities, crumbling empires, prehistoric ages and dying worlds.
  • A touch of horror. Much pulp fantasy shades into weird fiction, with monsters and ancient gods.
  • Vivid, sometimes purple prose. Atmosphere and sensation matter more than restraint.

Readers today should also expect some dated and offensive content. Racial stereotypes and crude gender roles are common in pulp fiction of this era.

Key writers and examples

What is an example of pulp fiction? In fantasy, these are the names most often cited:

  • Robert E. Howard: Conan the Cimmerian, from “The Phoenix on the Sword” (1932) onward, plus Kull, Solomon Kane and Bran Mak Morn. See our guide to Howard’s Conan books.
  • Clark Ashton Smith: the Zothique, Hyperborea and Averoigne story cycles, in ornate, decadent prose.
  • C.L. Moore: Jirel of Joiry, beginning with “Black God’s Kiss” (1934).
  • H.P. Lovecraft: best known for horror, but his “Dream Cycle” stories are pulp fantasy.
  • Fritz Leiber: Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser, who debuted in Unknown in 1939. Our Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser reading order covers the full series.
  • Edgar Rice Burroughs and A. Merritt: planetary romance and lost-world adventure.
  • Henry Kuttner and Leigh Brackett: Kuttner’s Elak of Atlantis, and Brackett’s swashbuckling interplanetary stories.

Outside fantasy, the most famous pulp heroes include the Shadow, Doc Savage, Tarzan and Zorro.

Pulp fantasy vs. epic fantasy

Pulp fantasy Epic (high) fantasy
Typical length Short stories, novelettes Long novels, multi-book series
Stakes Personal: gold, survival, revenge World-scale: kingdoms, the fate of the world
Hero Outsider, mercenary, thief Often chosen, noble or destined
Magic Rare, sinister, usually the villain’s Often systematic, sometimes heroic
Tone Fast, lurid, eerie Measured, elegiac, immersive
Key early model Howard’s Conan Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings

The most important subgenre to come out of pulp fantasy is sword and sorcery. The two terms overlap heavily, and many readers use them almost interchangeably. Our explainer on what sword and sorcery is goes deeper.

Pulp fantasy in games: Appendix N

If you have met the term “pulp fantasy” in tabletop gaming, this is why. In the 1979 Advanced Dungeons & Dragons Dungeon Masters Guide, Gary Gygax included a reading list known as Appendix N. It leaned heavily on pulp and pulp-descended fantasy: Howard, Leiber, Moorcock, Vance, Merritt, Burroughs, Lovecraft, de Camp and Pratt and others. Many of D&D’s assumptions come from these stories: adventurers out for treasure, dangerous wizards, lost temples, and a party of rogues instead of a fellowship of the chosen. Some of the “old-school” gaming community still uses “pulp fantasy” for that style of play.

Is pulp fantasy still written?

Yes, though not on pulp paper. The original magazines had mostly disappeared by the late 1950s. Their stories survived in paperback reprints, and the style continues in modern sword-and-sorcery magazines, small-press “new pulp” publishers and novels that consciously imitate the form. Our article on whether pulp magazines still exist looks at what has survived.

Where to start reading

The complete guide to classic and pulp fantasy

The Best Fantasy Short Stories of All Time
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →