Classic and Pulp Fantasy

What did Tolkien think of Conan the Barbarian?

Tolkien reportedly "rather liked" Howard's Conan stories, but the claim is secondhand. Here's where it comes from, what's known, and how the two authors compare.

On this page
  1. Where the “rather liked” claim comes from
  2. What we can and can’t say
  3. What Tolkien did say about other fantasy writers
  4. Tolkien and Howard compared
  5. Two roots of modern fantasy
  6. Reading both

As far as anyone knows, Tolkien said very little about Conan. The only widely cited evidence is a report from L. Sprague de Camp, the writer and editor who did much to revive Conan in the 1950s and 60s. De Camp said that Tolkien “rather liked” Robert E. Howard’s Conan stories. No comment on Howard by Tolkien himself is widely known, in his published letters or elsewhere. So the remark is best treated as an interesting but unconfirmed anecdote, not as proof that Tolkien was a fan.

Below, we look at where the claim comes from, what can reasonably be said about it, and how the two writers compare.

Where the “rather liked” claim comes from

The quote is usually traced to de Camp’s writing about the history of heroic fantasy, most often his 1976 book Literary Swordsmen and Sorcerers: The Makers of Heroic Fantasy. De Camp wrote about both Howard and Tolkien in his surveys of the genre, and he passed on Tolkien’s reported reaction to Conan.

The wording matters. “Rather liked” is mild, very English praise. Even if the report is accurate, it suggests that Tolkien enjoyed the stories well enough, not that he admired Howard or was influenced by him.

What we can and can’t say

A few points are worth keeping in mind before quoting the claim.

  • It’s secondhand. The remark reaches us through de Camp, not through anything Tolkien is known to have written. Tolkien wrote a great many letters, and a large selection has been published, but Howard is not known to be among the writers he discussed.
  • The reporter had a stake. De Camp was Conan’s leading editor and champion at the time. That doesn’t make the report untrue, but he had good reason to remember and repeat it.
  • Howard never read Tolkien. Howard died in June 1936. The Hobbit was published in September 1937 and The Lord of the Rings in 1954–55. Any influence could only have run one way.
  • We don’t know what Tolkien read. Conan was available in Gnome Press hardcovers in the 1950s and in Lancer paperbacks from 1966, but there is no record of which edition, or which stories, Tolkien might have seen.

The honest answer, then, is that Tolkien may have read some Conan and found it enjoyable, but the evidence is thin.

What Tolkien did say about other fantasy writers

Tolkien’s recorded opinions on other fantasy writers give useful context. He tended to admire older romance and myth, and he was often cool towards modern fantasy.

  • William Morris. Tolkien was openly influenced by Morris’s prose romances. As a young man, he wrote of wanting to turn part of the Finnish Kalevala into a story “somewhat on the lines of Morris’ romances”.
  • E.R. Eddison. In a letter, Tolkien said he read Eddison’s The Worm Ouroboros and its successors with real enjoyment for their literary merit. He also disliked Eddison’s invented names and the outlook of his characters.
  • George MacDonald. Tolkien’s view of MacDonald became more critical over time. An abandoned preface to MacDonald’s The Golden Key grew instead into his own story, Smith of Wootton Major.
  • H. Rider Haggard. Tolkien is reported to have said in an interview that She had interested him as a boy.

Against that background, mild enjoyment of a Texan pulp writer would be a little surprising, but not out of character. Like Morris and Eddison, Howard wrote about an archaic, heroic world in a heightened style.

Tolkien and Howard compared

The two writers are often paired, and they do have real things in common.

  • An invented prehistory of our own world. Howard set Conan in the “Hyborian Age”, a forgotten era before recorded history. He even wrote an essay, “The Hyborian Age”, tracing its rise and fall. Tolkien also described Middle-earth as our world at an imagined time in the remote past, not as another planet.
  • Northern myth. Both drew on Norse and Germanic legend. Howard’s “The Frost-Giant’s Daughter” is set among warring Æsir and Vanir in a frozen north. Tolkien was a professional scholar of the same literature.
  • Distrust of “progress”. Howard repeatedly sets vigorous barbarism against decadent civilisation. Tolkien distrusted industry and the machine, and preferred the rustic Shire.

The differences are larger:

Tolkien Howard
Form Long novels, carefully revised over many years Short stories and novellas written fast for magazines
Scale The fate of the world Personal survival, loot and revenge
Heroes Ordinary people, hobbits above all A lone, physically overwhelming adventurer
Magic Rare, subtle, sometimes benevolent (Gandalf, the Elves) Usually evil, ancient and monstrous
Moral world Clear good and evil, shaped by Tolkien’s Catholic faith Bleak and amoral, with a hero who lives by a personal code
Tone Elegiac, with eventual hope Violent, sensual, often fatalistic

Two roots of modern fantasy

Tolkien and Howard are often seen as the two main ancestors of modern fantasy. One leads to epic or high fantasy, the other to sword and sorcery.

Their reputations grew in the same years. In the mid-1960s, American paperback editions of The Lord of the Rings became a campus phenomenon. At almost the same time, Lancer began its Conan paperbacks, edited by de Camp, many with famous Frank Frazetta covers. Readers coming to fantasy in that boom met both at once, and the contrast between them shaped how the genre was discussed for decades.

Not every sword-and-sorcery writer shared Tolkien’s supposed tolerance. Michael Moorcock, creator of Elric, criticised Tolkien sharply in his 1978 essay “Epic Pooh”, calling his fiction comforting and conservative. Elric himself was written partly as a deliberate inversion of the Conan type. Our Elric reading order is a good place to start with Moorcock.

Reading both

If you know Tolkien well but have never read Howard, the original Conan stories are short, quick and easy to try. Start with “The Tower of the Elephant” or “Beyond the Black River”. Our guide to Robert E. Howard’s Conan books explains which editions print Howard’s own texts.

If you’d like to see Tolkien at short length, “Leaf by Niggle” is one of his finest stories, and it features in our list of the best fantasy short stories of all time. For the magazine world Howard wrote for, see our explainer on what pulp fantasy is.

The complete guide to classic and pulp fantasy

The Best Fantasy Short Stories of All Time
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →